United States v. Novak

Morrison and Novak (defendants) sold “herbal incense” from their retail store, JC Moon, in Ashland, Wisconsin. The substances included XLR-11, UR-144, PB- 22, and 5F-PB-22, which then were not listed on the controlled substance schedules but were similar to scheduled controlled substances. Undercover law enforcement officers made 28 controlled purchases at JC Moon and learned that defendants hid a significant portion of their cash income from the IRS by “skimming” large bills from the cash registers. From 2010 to 2012, defendants under-reported JC Moon’s business income by $575,752 for a tax loss of $186,095. Defendants pleaded guilty to violation of the Controlled Substances Analogue Act, 21 U.S.C. 813 and tax fraud, Novak was sentenced to 96 months and Morrison to 48 months in prison. The Seventh Circuit affirmed, noting a Supreme Court holding that holding that the Analogue Act is not unconstitutionally vague due to its scienter requirement and rejecting challenges to the court’s acceptance of their pleas and to the sentences. The totality of the circumstances surrounding Novak’s and Morrison’s guilty pleas indicated that they entered into those pleas voluntarily and with sufficient understanding of the charges against them; there was sufficient factual basis for the pleas. View "United States v. Novak" on Justia Law